I’ve noticed something recently. I feel guilty about my daydreams, my imagination, my intuition, my deeply held visions.
I just do. As soon as a big one pops up, I feel guilty. Then, I am discovering, I look around to find something to confirm my guilt. Something, that is, to confirm that it’s wrong for me to dream this or that.
And, no surprise, I can always find evidence that my dreams, imagination, intuition, and visions are wrong. Not wrong as in incorrect, but wrong as in immoral, unethical, harmful.
Such fun. I was thinking about the life I lived growing up, in which guilt featured prominently as a motivator. My upbringing has often been referred to as sheltered, presumably because I spent most of it in church or around church-type people. I wonder what I was sheltered from, though? I spent my formative years listening to harangue after harangue about how if I weren’t saved I’d be going to a literal fiery burning hell forever; and if I am saved it’s my duty to go out and save as many other people in the world as possible from that same fate. It was terrifying. I was subjected to constant lectures on something called sin, the rules about which seemed to change with the speaker (always with Bible verses for backup, though), and the path to virtue seemed to be to feel terribly guilty.
In fact, the only way to freedom and happiness was to feel completely guilty and entirely worthless. So I wonder, in what way, exactly, was my upbringing sheltered? It was pretty brutal from an emotional perspective. If my children were subjected to the sorts of things I had to hear every day of the week, I would remove them immediately from the situation. I can’t believe that children have to hear such horrible things about themselves, about the universe, and about the parts of life that we don’t really understand.
So here I am, decades later, still peeling back the layers of what it means to live freely. Again and again and over again I come up against this intrusive and physically painful feeling of guilt, of worthlessness. It has nothing to do with who I am, how I live, or what I believe now. It has nothing to do with my hopes for the future. It has nothing to do with my dreams. But it still occupies a large space in my psyche.
Recently, I posted a short quote from my favorite detective, Sherlock Holmes. The essence of it was that once you have removed all other possible solutions, the one remaining, however improbable, has to be the truth. This quote is my life jacket in these days. I am removing possible solutions and looking at the improbable truth.
Removing the solution that freedom is bought through believing in one’s innate worthlessness.
Removing the solution that happiness is obtained through feeling completely guilty.
Removing the solution that sin exists, and can be defined, and brings on a literal fiery eternal hell (I cannot imagine what my people were thinking of when they told little tiny me, a determined people-lover and people-pleaser, such a horrible thing).
Removing the solution that my dreams are wrong, sinful, inspired by selfishness or worse.
Removing the solution that my intuition is inherently and horribly evil.
There are more removals to be done. But when they are gone, the improbable truth that remains is that I can feel free when I believe I am worthy. I can feel happy when I feel self-love. I can understand that people do not always treat each other well, and there certainly exists a level of behavior that I will probably always call evil – but my little four year old self wasn’t evil, and my inner self isn’t, still. I can understand that my dreams are really just my life spinning out into the future. And my intuition is how I know my dreams have a shimmer on them.
I have a couple of places in my life where I am testing this out right now, big time. And I think that is why I am feeling the backlash of the old guilt. These couple of places are huge priorities for me, and they go against everything I was ever taught, even as an adult, that I should do, be, or believe. But they are me. They are me. I have few priorities in life. But these few – they are there because they reflect my inner self.
I wonder, too, about something – I have times when I feel the guilt and the shame and the unworthiness and all of those feelings that swamped my childhood psyche, are just gone. And I’m wondering these days about what I can do to fill that space that has been occupied by guilt for so much of my life. It’s a big space. What do I want to put there? What do I want to do with it?
I think I might use it as a space for singing. It is really big, and has hard walls, and so it’s bound to have good acoustics. And I know that one of the reasons I HAVE to sing (I don’t speak my priorities aloud much, but this one is clear and open), is because when I sing I believe in my dreams.
Growing up how I did, coming out later in life as I did, and living with restrictions that put me in a box, have left me with – the exact opposite of what my upbringing was supposed to bring. Because at the end of the day I keep reaching for something happy and free, just over the rainbow…

19 comments
Comments feed for this article
January 12, 2013 at 1:14 pm
Heidi Miller
Sometimes, most times, I am glad I did not grow up in a church. I think in the right hands, spirituality and religiion should fill a person up and bring them peace. But too many hands have twisted and wrung out the essence of spirituality leaving the dirty side that practically punishes the believer. It is a hard feeling to get rid of as it has been there longer than you can remember. I hope you can purge those feelings and fill your soul with peace and let the music take you over the rainbow.
January 12, 2013 at 1:17 pm
MakingSpace
Thank you Heidi! I am realizing that as I have just taken a particular step toward a larger life goal, I’m having several days of feeling unsettled, overworked, and really tired. I think that state of mind/body allows the old patterns to come back, and the best thing is to really take good care of myself. Speaking of which, nap time!!
January 12, 2013 at 1:29 pm
zannalyn
When they told you those horrible things, they thought they were saving your eternal soul. And that is no excuse. Only because they were/are so cut off from their own tender hearts for so long could they do that to a child. None of that is in any way your fault or under your control.
You know I know what you mean about all of this. My mom has a long term involvement with Child Evangelism Fellowship, whose purpose is to do to as many children as possible just what was done to you and me: scare us into following their so-called religion. Grrrrrrrrr…
I have imagined going back and whispering in my child self’s ear “They’re lying!” And I have used advice I got from some fundies as a sort of map: the truth is exactly the opposite of what they told me. (thinking here of the summer camp director who told teenage me that no matter how much I prayed and asked to be guided, I could NEVER trust my feelings.)
Anyhow,you’ve got this space with great acoustics, so keep dreaming and keep singing! And keep taking naps.
January 13, 2013 at 7:08 am
MakingSpace
Yes, CEF was a big feature of my growing up and early adult years. It shocks me now to think about what was done to us as children, and what is done to children, in this religious framework. It really is the epitome of committing abuse and calling it love.
Your second paragraph resonates so much.
I had a great oracle and tarot reading last night with a friend, and one of the oracle cards was a butterfly coming out of a chrysalis. It gave me a completely different image for this process. It doesn’t have to be the evacuation of a space that is, nevertheless, going to be there. It can be a process of growing out of something that is no longer needed. You can’t rush that process, but it is a natural growth experience. Very encouraging.
January 14, 2013 at 6:43 am
zannalyn
Yes! on the butterfly. Love it.
“committing abuse and calling it love”… this is the nasty twisted way of it. Straight out nastiness is easier to take than the mix of love and abuse… it’s when they are twisted together that it’s most horrible, ime.
Fly on, butterfly! <3
January 14, 2013 at 7:32 pm
MakingSpace
By the way, these were the oracle cards Rob Brezsny uses.
And yes, calling abuse love is especially twisted. I’m learning the difference now, thankfully.
I shall fly.
January 14, 2013 at 12:44 am
Jet Black
What a beautifully open, honest and inspiring post. And the Eva Cassidy clip is perfect! It’s the first post I’ve read from your blog and it makes me want to read more. It also made me think of Jeanette Winterson, an English lesbian writer who also grew up in a hellfire and brimstone proselytising Christian home. I don’t know if you’ve read any of her work, but you may want to check out ‘Why Be Happy When You Could Be Normal?’ (http://www.jeanettewinterson.com/pages/content/index.asp?PageID=611).
January 14, 2013 at 7:35 pm
MakingSpace
First of all, thank you so much for your kind words, and I do hope you enjoy reading other posts here.
Second, OHHHH WOWWW. The link you posted from Jeanettte Winterson – oh my gosh. I think I have to read that book sometime when I don’t have anything else going on and I can go to therapy right afterwards. It sounds like an awesome, powerful, incredible book. Thank you for the introduction.
January 14, 2013 at 11:21 pm
Jet Black
My pleasure! 📚👍😊
January 15, 2013 at 3:30 am
Tracey
Excellent suggested reading!
January 15, 2013 at 9:20 pm
MakingSpace
Truly!
January 14, 2013 at 9:01 am
Lexie C
I hadn’t found any words for this post other than a deep felt and resounding applause for the last 2 paragraphs. I’m sorry for your constrictive and guilt-heavy childhood, had one of those myself and in a lot ways still fight against it’s restraints. Keep dreaming, keep singing, keep believing.
I clicked over to the Jeanette Winterson site offered above. Wow. I loved this post under “column”- http://www.jeanettewinterson.com/pages/column/column_item.asp?columnID=166&column_Category=2012 It shares a bit from her book and some thoughts on her Christmas rituals.
I particularly liked “We love what we have learned to love. We hate what we have learned to hate. The task is to get beyond we have learned and create a reality for ourselves.” This is where I am right now- creating a reality for myself that is authentic and less harmful to my inner child. It’s a difficult task full of potholes and switchbacks but I have to believe that there IS an “over the rainbow”!
btw, I really enjoyed this beautiful version of “Over the Rainbow”
January 14, 2013 at 7:42 pm
MakingSpace
Oh wow, Lexie. What a post about Christmas. So much in there. Thank you for that link.
You know, I’m barely just now starting to figure out that love is really all there is. If I’m living out of love, everything just kind of THUNKS into place. If I’m resisting it, I’m scared almost all the time. I gotta post something about this, I think.
Eva Cassidy was a huge talent, and gone too soon. I love all of her music.
January 15, 2013 at 4:03 am
Lexie
Maybe that is one of my fundamental problems- I’m a huge skeptic of love- not the love I have for my kidlets or family, but outreaching love, romantic love, even love of self. It ties in there with trust- another thing that I find myself estranged from. I’m putting the “It’s all about love” post in the simmer pot to mull for a while.
I’m very glad that for you things are thunking into place!
January 15, 2013 at 9:21 pm
MakingSpace
Yes, trust and love do seem linked. I’ve been playing around with those two concepts/feelings at the same time, and they do seem to be bound together somehow.
January 15, 2013 at 3:50 am
Tracey
The more I am separated from the evangelical way of thinking the more I realize that religious zealotry imposed on children, in any form, is nothing short of child abuse. Well meaning, but irrational and abusive nonetheless.
When I get into my self flagellation mode I like to counter it with a campy song I found comforting as an adolescent. Tim Curry from “The Rocky Horror Picture Show” sings a song near the end of the film with the repeated line, “Don’t dream it, be it.” He’s talking about sexual freedom but I found it works for everything from attempting a half gainer off the spring board to coming out.
If nothing else it gives me satisfaction that I am getting my guiding words from a source that would make a Biblical literalist’s head explode. Call it defiance I guess.
Still loving your posts and sharing them with my yahoo group of fellow wayward women over 40 who are traversing the waters of coming out. You are inspiring to many. Be gentle with yourself and keep putting the guilt in a cage where it belongs.
Don’t dream it… Be it.
January 15, 2013 at 4:06 am
Lexie
LOVE this comment!
January 15, 2013 at 9:23 pm
MakingSpace
Agree!
January 15, 2013 at 9:23 pm
MakingSpace
Haha – this is awesome! Thank you! Yes, the religious zealotry is child abuse, pure and simple. And I’m glad you’ve mixed up the Bible and the Rocky Horror Picture Show in your brain to help you overcome it. EXCELLENT. And please keep sharing my blog with your yahoo group, and let them know they’re all welcome here. We have the best music.